The Contract Requires It, but Does the Policy Provide It?
Posted on October 21, 2026
By: Saurabh Bangar
Construction contracts often require insurance protections using familiar terms such as “primary and non-contributory,” “waiver of subrogation,” and “additional insured.” Those words create contractual obligations, but they do not themselves amend an insurance policy. If the policy does not provide the promised protection, the insured may face an uninsured liability and a separate claim for failing to obtain the insurance required under the contract.
How Can Claims Obligations Under the Contract Conflict with the Insurance Policy?
Insurance policies require the insured to take steps to reserve entitlement to coverage. Such steps include prompt notice of a claim, cooperation with the insurer, delivery of legal documents, preservation of evidence, and insurer consent before an insured makes voluntary payments or agrees to a settlement. These policy requirements can conflict with the insured’s obligations under the construction contract, which may require a party to repair damage immediately, indemnify and defend another party, or assume responsibility for a loss.
These competing obligations can pull the insured in different directions. A contractor may attempt to comply with an indemnity provision by admitting responsibility or paying remediation costs, while potentially prejudicing its insurance coverage by acting without the insurer’s consent. Conversely, waiting for the insurer’s direction may place the contractor in breach of contractual obligations concerning emergency work or the protection of the site.
To manage this, the construction contract should distinguish between urgent measures required to protect persons or property and the later adjustment or settlement of a claim. It should also identify who is responsible for:
- notifying the relevant insurers;
- preserving damaged materials and other evidence;
- providing project records;
- coordinating communications with insurers; and
- managing the defence of a claim.
This is particularly important where the owner places the builder’s risk policy, but the contractor controls the site and possesses the evidence and project records required to support a proof of loss.
Does “Primary and Non-Contributory” Wording Determine Which Policy Responds First?
Not necessarily. More than one policy may respond to a construction loss, including a wrap-up policy, a contractor’s annual commercial general liability policy, an owner’s policy, or coverage available to an additional insured. Construction contracts commonly attempt to establish priority by requiring one policy to be “primary and non-contributory.”
That wording is a promise between the contracting parties. By itself, it does not amend either party’s insurance policy or conclusively determine how responsibility will be allocated between insurers. The promised priority should also be reflected in the policy wording or an endorsement. If it is not, the insured may have obtained insurance but still breached the construction contract by failing to procure the required terms. Meanwhile, the insurers may determine priority under the “other insurance” provisions contained in their respective policies.
Is a Certificate of Insurance Enough?
A certificate of insurance may confirm matters such as policy limits and the names of insured parties, but it does not establish the scope of protection required by the construction contract. The policy and its endorsements determine whether the required priority, additional-insured status, cross-liability protection, and separation-of-insureds wording are actually provided.
The insurance review needs to go beyond the certificate. The contractual requirements should be compared against the actual policy wording and applicable endorsements to determine whether the insurance provides the protection promised in the construction contract.
Is a Waiver of Claims the Same as a Waiver of Subrogation?
No. A contractual waiver of claims and a waiver of subrogation address different rights.
A contractual waiver of claims governs the rights of the contracting parties against one another. A waiver of subrogation concerns the insurer’s ability to pursue the insured’s recovery rights after the insurer has paid or assumed liability for a loss. Section 36 of British Columbia’s Insurance Act addresses an insurer’s subrogation rights after payment or assumption of liability for a loss.
Construction contracts often seek to prevent recovery against project participants by including waivers of claims or requiring the parties to obtain waivers of subrogation. However, a contractual requirement to obtain that protection does not itself bind the insurer or amend the policy. The insurer’s recovery rights may remain unless the policy permits the pre-loss waiver or contains the necessary endorsement.
The distinction is important. The parties may have agreed in contract not to pursue one another, yet the insurance policy may not contain the corresponding protection required to prevent the insurer from pursuing the insured’s recovery rights after paying a loss.
What Other Insurance Gaps Should Project Participants Consider?
The scope of each required protection should be clearly identified. The relevant construction contract and insurance provisions should address:
- which parties are intended to be protected, including appropriate subcontractors and consultants;
- whether the protection applies to losses covered by insurance or only to insurance proceeds actually received;
- whether the protection continues following completion of the work; and
- whether the requirements are consistent across the prime contract, subcontracts, policies, and endorsements.
Gaps between the prime contract, subcontracts, and policy wording may leave a project participant exposed despite the project’s intended allocation of risk.
What Are the Key Takeaways?
Construction insurance clauses should be tested against the actual policy wording. In particular:
- Contractual claims obligations should be coordinated with the policy’s notice, cooperation, evidence-preservation, consent, and settlement requirements.
- Contractual language requiring insurance to be “primary and non-contributory” does not itself amend the policy or determine priority between insurers.
- A certificate of insurance should not replace a review of the policy and applicable endorsements.
- A contractual waiver of claims does not necessarily prevent an insurer from exercising rights of subrogation.
- The prime contract, subcontracts, policies, and endorsements should provide a consistent allocation of insurance risk.
The central legal question is not simply whether insurance exists, but whether the policy delivers the protection that the construction contract requires.
The foregoing is provided for general informational purposes only, does not constitute legal advice, and shall not be relied upon as legal advice. Legal advice should be obtained concerning the particular contract, policy, project, and circumstances. Please contact the author for advice concerning a specific matter.
If you have any questions regarding this article, please contact the author, Saurabh Bangar, or any member of our Construction Law group.